Showing posts with label Stephen Sondheim. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Stephen Sondheim. Show all posts

Wednesday, 26 July 2017

Merrily We Roll Along, Watch This, Southbank Theatre, The Lawler, Saturday July 15th 2017

"Merrily We Roll Along, Watch This, Southbank Theatre, The Lawler, Saturday July 15th 2017

"Merrily We Roll Along", was presented by Watch This at the Southbank Theatre, The Lawler, on Saturday July 15th 2017

For those new to my blog I write about the holistic experience of attending the theatre. I buy my own tickets. So if you want a re-telling of the story please refer to the links for further information or for further insights.  Note, that I may provide different links for repeated main words or phrases.  I write for my memories of what I have seen, and is more of a stream of consciousness.

"Merrily We Roll Along", was presented by Watch This at the Southbank Theatre, The Lawler, on Saturday July 15th 2017

"Merrily We Roll Along" by Stephen Sondheim, has some of his most hum-able tunes.  There are Sondheim fans and clubs and societies all over the world.  Fans will argue about their favourite song or show or performer.  I am fortunate to have seen many Sondheim productions.

"Merrily We Roll Along", has been reworked throughout the years by various companies all over the world.  This musical speaks so much about regret, hopes, dreams, friendships, success and failure, and consequences. Fans will argue about what is the better version of the show and which opening and closing works better.  I prefer the original opening and closing as it bookends the show neatly with the final class snapshot and puts everything into perspective.  

This version by Watch This opens with the success of Frank's latest movie.  Starting after the context setting Graduation Scene rushes the context and does not allow the audience time to be introduced to each of the main characters.  The show is about understanding how people change over time from their hopeful, idealistic youth.

The direction by Sara Grenfell worked on many fronts and was limited by the restrictive and intrusive stage design. Sara Grenfell brought out some strengths in individual characterisations and performances in "Merrily We Roll Along".  The staging was quite good given the dominance of the staircase.   The placement of the two pianos balanced the sound, and provided a sense of a creative studio.

The accents were confusing as the actors switched between Australian and standard American dialects.  Then, the performers would sing with American accents.  I could understand the use of the regional American accents for cameo roles but this highlighted the error in judgement in using varied and indeterminate accents elsewhere.

Musical direction by Cameron Thomas is at its best with the pianist.  It would have been great to hear all of the brass and string orchestrations, and surprisingly I enjoyed the piano version.  Overall individual singing was not up to scratch with this score as only one song was completely sung in tune.  The best part of the singing was the ensemble harmonies.

The best part of this version of "Merrily We Roll Along" was Cameron Thomas as the pianist.  He was not distracting, as was the case with the musician in the "Heart Is  A Wasteland" at Malthouse Theatre on Wednesday July 12th 2017.

Set Design by Emily Collett was inventive but too cramped as the staircase took up about a third of the stage.  The staircase paid homage to "Follies" and created the symbol of status and power.  The staircase emphasised the school graduation opening version that did not occur.  The year 1965 was highlighted on a card in Act Two and made me question why more labeling of years did not occur throughout the production.

The red curtains upstage were effectively used for entrances, and, for the revue and wedding scene.

The set was too large for the space as the actors tried to squeeze behind the black curtain upstage left. This distracted from the flow of the show and highlighted the cramming of too much into such a small space. As the actors squeezed behind the staircase to make entrances via a black curtain, they revealed many entrances: which was both distracting and drew focus away from the central action.

The design impacted upon the sight-lines on the actions. The suitcases were used in a gag that had the audience in the back row rising from their seats to see Charley in the suitcase.  This small section was the only part that was staged too far downstage.  (This is a compliment as so many shows at Chapel Off Chapel are staged too far downstage.)

The costumes mainly worked, but repeating the silver/black suit for Mary was a time period issue, as was Frank's cream jacket.  A torn pair of black pants was not a good look, nor was the cuffs on the men's jackets.  I appreciate accidents can happen and a tear can occur on stage during a production - but the dominating staircase added to the prospect of accidents.

Appropriate historical make-up changes from 1979 to earlier periods were noticeable on Ana Mitsikas who played Dory Bunker and Mrs Spencer.  These small details added to the individual actor's characters.

Choreography by David Wynen worked best in the montage sequences for the ensemble in the various party scenes.  David Wynen also worked some magic with the very long "Bobby and Jackie and Jack" number as he referenced some important poses and group formations from the early 1960s' era.  David Wynen could benefit in researching and creating more historical poses from many of the famous Kennedy photographs available in "Life", Time" and other magazines.

The end of Act One sequence had many in the audience cringing or looking at each other - as this section was so jarring and out of place with the choreography that had preceded.  This section was corny as it appeared if it was the big dance number and did not really tell the story of transition to the cruise, as the earlier choreography had purpose.  Choreographically, this finale to Act One was well staged but not in context of the show.  The dance moves of 1979 needed to be more clearly differentiated from those of the late 1950's and early 1960's.  I look forward to seeing more of David Wynen's work in the future, as he is a choreographer to watch.

The performances varied especially with the accents as they changed from Australian to Canadian to American.  The show would have worked better had they all used American accents as they sang using American pronunciation.  Overall the diction in both dialogue and songs was poor, with a three exceptions.  Only three performers could project their voices to us seated in the back row.  

Sadly, only one song was entirely sung in tune.  The singing overall was ordinary from individuals but the ensemble harmonies were pleasant.  This may sound harsh but the cast did capture the essence of the heart of the show. 

Some of my favourite moments included Frank played by Lyall Brooks playing the piano and the transitions between Cameron Thomas  playing the piano.

The television interview scene is a sure hit and was expertly handled by Vidya Makan as KT, Nelson Gardner as Charley and Lyall Brooks as Frank.  Nelson Gardner's characterisation of Charley was superb from his first hunched over entrance to this show-stopping scene with the "Network" meltdown song "Franklin Shephard, Inc".  Every move, gesture and lyric had the requisite emotional connection.  Sadly his later song was out of tune.  Nelson Gardner is a talent to watch in the future.

Other favourite moments included the sputnik spotting roof-top scene when Mary meets Charley and Frank.  This was one of the few scenes where my heart leapt at the emotional connection and honesty between the players.  More of this emotional connection was needed in earlier (later chronological scenes) especially with "Old Friends".

Beth played by Sophie Weiss sang the iconic song of yearning  "Not A Day Goes By".  This was the only song sung completely in tune, and had a sincere emotional connection.  Sadly, we could barely could hear the song in the back row.

Adrian Barila played Scotty, Cameraman and a Photographer.  Adrian Barila differentiated his various cameo roles: in particular he had Scotty using a supercilious eye brow lift and rotated shouldered posture

Nicole Melloy as Mary provided some good laughs with her journey backwards in time to allow us to see why she took up drinking.  Her performance was restrained and showed her growing younger as the innocent Barnard College student.  Nicole Melloy lightened her voice and body to show a youthfulness at her first meeting Frank and Charley. 

Lyall Brooks,  Nelson Gardner and Nicole Melloy and Mark Doggett did a fine job with "Opening Doors", as it is such pivotal and important song that gives context and depth to the show.

I yearned for "The Hills of Tomorrow" finale as I could visualise the cast on that dominating staircase.  This original song gives the show a more sense of completeness to the show.

"Merrily We Roll Along" is one of my favourite Sondheim musicals, and still brings tears of joy and hope to my eyes when I listen to it.   "Merrily We Roll Along"  should be filmed, not as a stage show but as a proper movie to enable the audience to access the time shifts and the ageing of characters.  Sondheim was way ahead of his time writing this musical as it will work best as a proper film with all of the historical references.  I would prefer they used the original Graduation opening and closing as it is so cinematic.  I think Sondheim had written a screenplay for a movie musical and not your traditional stage musical.

Characterisations and acting obtained an 8/10 while individual singing obtained a 5/10.  Ensemble singing obtained a 7/10.   Staging obtained a 6/10.


Overall "Merrily We Roll Along",  presented by Watch This at the Southbank Theatre, The Lawler, on Saturday July 15th 2017 obtained a 6.5/10.

Friday, 7 November 2014

Passion, Playhouse Theatre, Thursday November 6th 2014

Passion, Playhouse Theatre, Thursday November 6th 2014

"Passion" plays for a short season at the Playhouse Theatre at Arts Centre Melbourne for four performances only.  "Passion" has music and lyrics by Stephen Sondheim and a book by James Lapine.

For those new to my blog I write about the holistic experience of attending the theatre and I do not retell the story.  Please click on my links to other sites for extra information.

"Passion" is presented by Life Like Company with a stellar cast of Australian musical theatre performers.  I purchased two Dress Circle tickets for $135 each in the A row.  I was shocked that these great seats were available and on hindsight I can understand people's reluctance to spend this amount on a new group.  Though these seats were a little pricey for the quality of the entire production I have paid more for another lesser quality show.

I have seen "Passion" before at Chapel Off Chapel and thought that production was the Australian professional premiere.  Maybe it was a co-operative production?  I try not to compare productions but I had not written my blog back then.  I want to acknowledge that the Chapel Off Chapel production had a minimalist set and did a stellar job on a much smaller stage with magnificent harmonies.

The pre-show announcement asked that mobile phones be "turned off."  I hope this is the new standard compared to their normal request to switch phones to "silent."

"Passion" stars Kane Alexander as Captain Giorgio Bachetti who has a mistress Clara played by Sylvie Paladino.  They begin the musical in bed singing "Happiness" and the staging is anything but happiness. The singing is glorious but the emotional connection is anything but happiness, more like awkward lusty adventures.  There was no tenderness or seduction or passion but pure mechanical post-coital coy covering-up with the bed-sheets to hide their flesh or modesty patches from the audience.  The physical action lacked physical intimacy and was incongruent with the beautiful singing.

There was a detachment and aloofness between Clara and Giorgio.  It was as if the director was trying to emphasise the lack of passion or maybe there was no emotional connection between the actors.

The role of Fosca is the ugly duckling role in "Passion" as she teaches Giorgio about love and passion.  Fosca was played with restraint by Theresa Borg.  Her screams varied in terrorising us as did her physical condition.  I wanted to see more physical connection to Fosca's mental health issues.  Though sung beautifully I yearned for more rich darkness in her vocal connection.

Lighting by Rob Sowinksi and Tom Warneke was confused and ill-defined.  The performers either could not find their light or there were too many shadows across their faces.  The lighting did not differentiate the sense of space or location enough in the first third of the show.  It did improve but the lighting design came across as a last minute decision.

My favourite aspect of the lighting was when the desk was used by Clara with one lighting plot.  Then the desk was used in the bedroom with Fosca and Giorgio with a lighting change.  This lighting to differentiate scenes was what this show needed more of.

The set design by Rob Sowinski, Kim Ritchie and Dave Bramble used some elaborate and heavy period furniture pieces, including a large dining table, desks and pool table.  They were awkwardly moved about by the military clad actors.  Some times the poor actors had to heave and lug the heavy dining table or pool table off the stage.

The use of the sheer curtains gave a voyeuristic atmosphere to some scenes particularly when we could glimpse Fosca in the background.  These curtains got in the way on a number of occasions with the performers trying to navigate around them with the heavy furniture.  With a longer season this would be corrected.

The orchestra played magnificently as led by Guy Simpson.  Why though did one player read the programme during sections when he was not playing?  This was very distracting and sometimes more interesting to watch the orchestra rather than the stage.

I felt the staging, with more time, would become more confident, as it came across as very awkward on occasions.  Particularly with the stumbling into curtains and retakes on some dialogue.

I understand this is a short four performance season but the length of the men's hair varied so much that it looked ill-defined for the military characters.  While some of the men were all disciplined and well groomed the others were dishevelled and rebellious looking.

The support roles give few opportunities to show their characters and some were more defined than others.  The dining scene allowed us more of an opportunity to distinguish each character.  Some of the characterisations were a little wooden and stilted.  I hope that this was their historical period and military choice.

The costumes by Wendy Findlater were of the period and suitable. MMMM Wendy Findlater sounds like a made up name.  Plus she is the Assistant Stage Manager.   MMMMMMM!

There was a wardrobe malfunction for Giorgio and I longed for Clara to adjust his epaulet with some tenderness.  The more this was ignored, the more prominent the wardrobe malfunction became.  In the next scene Giorgio's epaulet was adjusted and again highlighted a missed intimate moment between Clara and Giorgio.

Director, Neil Gooding has produced a fine ensemble of performers that brought "Passion" to life.  With more they could have made this work radiate and excel.  Though what I loved about this production was the various levels the main characters developed relating to the many definitions of passion from lust, love, desire, obsession and struggle. Another definition relates to the strong and powerful emotions not only felt by Fosca, but also juxtaposed by the ever present "strong and powerful" military characters.

I too "struggled" with the military characters moving the heavy furniture.  Maybe this struggle was intentional by the director, as many people when they move house struggle to let go of a favourite piece of furniture and take it with them to fit inappropriately in their new abode.  If this "struggle" to move the sets was intentional, then make it more obvious.  It makes sense in respect to camping and decamping the military, but also decamping and setting up a new relationship or a new house.

The musical "Passion" also highlights the grieving patterns that people can experience.  Giorgio goes through two simultaneous grief cycles for Carla and for Fosca.  This culminates in his acceptance of love for Fosca.  Someone should do a PHD study on these two simultaneous grief cycles that Giorgio experiences.

The various letters between Carla and Giorgio show different stages of their relationship.  In Giorgio's letters to Carlo he talks about Fosca.  Giorgio is denying Fosca and is angry or disgusted by her.  He has a turning point where he is depressed by his relationship with Carla and also does not realise that he misses Fosca.  There is the final acceptance that his relationship with Carla is over and the acceptance of his love for Fosca.  This is where Kane Alexander excelled in his balancing of the two grief cycles.  His vocal gymnastics over the evening, showed us the range of emotions that finally resigned itself in his acceptance of self with his love for Fosca.

Fosca too goes through her grieving cycle and this manifests itself in her mental illness.  Remember that depression used to be called melancholia.

Carla also goes through her grief cycle.  This could include grieving for refusing to be with Giorgio and not wanting to give up her child.  This imaginary grief counterpoints the reality of what we see with Fosca's public displays.  Both Carla and Fosca have different imaginations: Carla's what could be in the future, compared to Fosca's what is now.

Again this is where Sylvie Paladino and Theresa Borg have hit these grief cycles on the head with accuracy in their vocal delivery.  I could hear the despair of Theresa Borg's longing while with Sylvie Paladino there was a yearning and lustful desire for Giorgio.

The Musical Direction by Guy Simpson is the highlight of  "Passion" with such a fine orchestra playing Sondheim's score.  Guy has also ensured that the performers sing Sondheim's score with reverence.  The harmonies were beautiful particularly between Clara, Giorgio and Fosca.  While the harmonies for the men's ensemble were a bit unbalanced in volume levels at times.  The ensemble of men played the supporting roles with varying levels of success.  Small sections of the individual singing was flat and out of tune. I was very impressed with the diction as it was clear but not pedantic.

My favourite part of "Passion" was the singing of Kane Alexander, Sylvie Paladino and Theresa Borg.

I look forward to seeing more work by Life Like Company.

Overall this production gets a 7.5/10.